Our Story: A Slice of Tradition and Excellence

At Tawas Bay Pizza Company, we believe that the secret to the perfect pizza starts with the finest ingredients and the right techniques. That’s why we’ve gone the extra mile to bring you a truly unique and unbeatable pizza experience.

Our dough recipe is a cherished gift from the legendary Goodfellas Pizzeria in Staten Island, NY — six-time World Pizza-Making Champions. Their expertise in crafting the perfect dough has been passed down to us, ensuring that every bite of our pizza is soft, flavorful, and perfectly textured.

To elevate our pizza even further, we’ve paired this exceptional dough with a traditional brick oven from the NY Brick Oven Company. This oven, built to exacting standards, ensures that each pizza is baked to perfection, creating a crispy crust and smoky, flavorful finish that’s impossible to replicate.

Together, the award-winning dough and our state-of-the-art brick oven make Tawas Bay Pizza Company’s pizzas a cut above the rest. Every pizza we serve is the result of decades of expertise, passion, and the pursuit of perfection.

Come taste the difference. It’s pizza, perfected.